Circular Time

Circular_TimeIt’s been a while since I listened to the Big Finish audio Circular Time and I’ve been meaning to write a review about it, so today’s the day. I listened to it on the way back from Victoria, and I enjoyed it quite a lot.

Spoilers ahead. You can’t really write a review without at least a few spoilers.

Circular Time is a Fifth Doctor audio with Nyssa as his sole companion, which places it between “Time-Flight” (the Doctor finally gets Tegan to Heathrow, leaving ) and “Arc of Infinity” (Tegan accidentally encounters the Doctor in Amsterdam and rejoins the TARDIS crew). It’s a collection of four stories titled after the seasons of the year and has a general theme of the time and life, of death and renewal, and cyclic change. It was written by Paul Cornell, the author of “Human Nature”/”Family of Blood,” and it supports my realization earlier this month that he’s my favorite Doctor Who writer.

“Spring” has the Doctor heading to a planet of an avian species at the behest of the High Council because a Time Lord has left Gallifrey and integrated himself into their society, apparently attempting to make them evolve faster. This is probably the most straightforward of the four stories, but it is very interesting because it deals with what happens when a different Time Lord, not the Doctor, decides to break the non-interference policy. In this case, it’s not clear until the end what the Time Lord is trying to accomplish, and you accompany the Doctor on his journey of discovery, because he doesn’t really know what’s going on either.

In “Summer,” the Doctor meets Isaac Newton. While the plot of the story itself eludes me (I really need to listen to it again), the characterization of Newton is striking, almost disturbing. His mind doesn’t work like anyone else’s, and it’s scary to watch what happens to him as he deals with encountering the Doctor, a strange man that he knows is something from beyond his experience.

“Fall” is by far my favorite of the four, and is the one in which Nyssa takes as much of a primary role as the Doctor, if not more so. In this story, the Doctor explains the difference between circular time, the cyclic nature of seasons, days, and regeneration, and linear time, the journey from one point to another, from birth to death. The pair spend a few weeks on earth in autumn, so that the Doctor can play cricket in a village league, something that he likes because it is circular: cricket seasons always returns, and linear creatures like humans return to write themselves into history via stats and stories. Meanwhile, Nyssa takes the time to try to deal with the loss of Traken by writing a novel about her people, but she can’t write the linear story because she doesn’t want it to end. While both characters have a storyline here, they go in completely different directions than they want them to, and Nyssa’s is especially beautiful.

“Winter” is also a wonderful story, but I can’t really describe it at all without giving it entirely away. I will say it’s the only one of the stories that isn’t set between “Time-Flight” and “Arc of Infinity.”

As you can probably tell, Circular Time is not a typical Doctor Who adventure. There’s no running from monsters or evil plots to destroy worlds. These are introspective stories and very suited to the Fifth Doctor. I highly recommend them, especially “Autumn” and “Winter.”


6 responses to “Circular Time

  1. Brilliant review! I’d love to see more of your thoughts on audio adventures. (How did you like Phantasmagoria, Loups-Garoux, Singularity and Ringpullworld, by the way?)

    I’ve been listening to the audios set between “Enlightenment” and “The Kings Demons” (as well as Light at the End) and I love that I got the chance to really get to know Nyssa (as she comes back for a while, starting with “Cobwebs”, which, of course, comes after “Freakshow” from the Companion Chronicles, going by Five, Tegan and Turlough’s timelines) and listen to her interacting with everyone while simultaneously having her own mission: to cure another disease. First Lazar’s, now Richter’s, and she’s more grown up as well, but still the caring, intelligent woman we know from the show who shared such a strong friendship with Tegan.

    Your description of the Doctor interacting with Newton and him not having a mind quite like anyone else’s reminds me of the other people the Doctor’s encountered whose ways of thinking differed from the usual in some form, like Vincent Van Gogh and William Shakespeare from the new series.

    I thought in “Arc of Infinity” Tegan and someone she knew was being held hostage by Omega and that Five’s arrival in Amsterdam wasn’t accidental but actually a rescue attempt he made once she gave him a description of where she was against her captor’s will. Perhaps I’m not remembering it quite right, though. I tend to get things mixed up a bit.

    • I haven’t listened to too many of the audios – not enough time, what with my writing, rewatching series 6, and playing Diablo 3 with my husband. We’re taking a long drive this weekend and I’m going to introduce my husband to audios by playing Light at the End for him. I don’t know when I’m going to get to the others.

      Well, in “Arc of Infinity,” I said “accidental” because it was a matter of coincidence that Tegan got involved in the first place. If her cousin wasn’t in Amsterdam, she wouldn’t have been there at all, so she couldn’t have been used as bait to get the Doctor to go there.

      • Lucky! I love road trips! I want one!
        Anyway, no problem. You just keep having fun with whatever you’re doing and concentrating on the important stuff. 🙂
        Series 6 was 11 and the Ponds, right? We have that here, too. Amy’s one of my dad’s favorite companions.

        Right, I knew I was mixed up about something. I’m gonna have to go look at the transcript once more, sometime.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s