Spreading the addiction

The clockwork droids were just gorgeous!

The clockwork droids were just gorgeous!

Today, one of my co-workers, Maria, informed me that she and her husband watched “Blink” recently and really loved it, and are now going to start watching more Doctor Who. Muahaha! Another mind corrupted! She’s going to be streaming episodes off Netflix, but I recommended to her, if she wanted another good, unconnected episode to watch, that she check out “The Girl in the Fireplace.” I’m very much looking forward to seeing if she really gets into it. She’s an artist and seamstress, so I’m hoping she gets very addicted, if only to see if she starts doing cosplay, because she’d be great at it.

I find it a bit difficult to convince my friends and co-workers to check out Doctor Who for a variety of reasons. First, a lot of people have this idea in their head that they can’t start watching it from the modern series because they need to watch the classic series first, and of course there’s way too much classic series to watch. I try to convince them that they don’t need to do so, citing the fact that I’ve seen less than 1/4 of the classic series myself, but they always respond, “Well, I don’t want to start in the middle.” I think it’s probably just their polite way of telling me to shut up and go away.

I haven't yet convinced a single person to watch Broadchurch! What's wrong with you people?

I haven’t yet convinced a single person to watch Broadchurch! What’s wrong with you people?

Then there are the ones who’ve heard that the show is either a kid’s show or this wacky British show that’s hard for Americans to understand. It’s pretty to disabuse them of the notion that the show is targeted at children, but the second one is harder to argue past. I don’t find British shows to be difficult to understand, but I will admit that I had some problems with Broadchurch at first, because I’d never watched a British crime show and had no idea what things like “DI,” “DS,” and “SOCO.” meant. However, all that became clear in context. British humor and drama (and really, any other culture’s humor and drama) are harder to understand, but I do feel that they aren’t too alien. How do you convince someone to give new narrative and dialogue structure a try?

I think, though, the most difficult problem with enticing new people to give Doctor Who a try stems directly from the thing that’s the strength of the show: the fact that it’s so long-lived (even considering just the modern show) and its mutability. There are seven seasons to choose from and a person coming into it for the first time will usually have heard there are three different Doctors, with very different personalities: which one to choose? Do you start from the first episode of the first season, or from the first episode of the most recognizable/popular Doctor, or from the first episode from the most recent Doctor? I find that people are often scared off simply because it has that level of complexity.

What I like to do is offer them a few sample episodes to watch that demonstrate the quality of the show without requiring background knowledge (beyond knowing that the Doctor is an alien who travels through the universe in a time machine with companions). My two go-to episodes are, as noted above, “Blink” and “The Girl in the Fireplace”; both are completely self-contained. Of course, they are both Tenth Doctor episodes, so I’ve been trying to decide what I would recommend for the Ninth and Eleventh Doctors. I’m really not sure if I would recommend a Ninth Doctor episode, partly because he’s a lot more alien than the other two and partly because his best episodes require some background knowledge. “Rose” might be the only really good episode to recommend, but the old, hammy feel of the Autons could easily turn off a new viewer.

It’s also difficult to recommend an Eleventh Doctor episode, because even when background knowledge is not required, the season’s threads (the cracks in the wall, Amy’s visions of Madame Kovarian watching her, the mentions of the Impossible Girl) tend to infect every episode and could easily confuse the new viewer. I think the only episode that I would choose to introduce a friend to the Eleventh Doctor would be “Vincent and the Doctor.” Maybe there’s something in series 7 that I’m not remembering well enough that would be good (though I kind of doubt it).



5 responses to “Spreading the addiction

  1. Sorry about Broadchurch, too busy with ST:TNG. Maybe after that, I’ll consider it.

    Anyway, what you wrote reminded me of the time my mother and I went to a relative’s non-professional hockey game and I talked to her daughter, who was a bit younger than myself, about Doctor Who. She was under the (rather mistaken, in my opinion) impression that it was like “American Horror Story”, something I looked up on TVTropes later and decided never *ever* to watch (::shudders::), but I explained to her that it was more like the Sherlock Holmes stories she knew and loved. The Doctor was like Holmes, using his expertise to solve the mysteries needed to save the planets, and his companions were like Watson, who asks the questions that help him find the right solutions. Hopefully, she’s watched a bit since then. We’re not in contact, unfortunately.

    I always recommend to others what was recommended to me: Start with the first series with Nine, go forward as far as you can go and go back into the classics while you wait for the new stuff to come out.

    • I’ve found that Nine is often difficult to understand (both personality-wise and accent-wise) for people who aren’t used to British drama. A friend of mine started from Nine and could not grok him at all. Then he moved into Ten and his saccharine relationship with Rose and gave up halfway through the season. We tried to get him to watch Donna, but he didn’t want to waste any more of his time.

      • I suppose the accent thing is true, but we really do get a lot of good background information from him for those who don’t want to start at the very beginning of everything and the set up of Rose as a character, showing the development of their…relationship, however one chooses to define it.
        It’s too bad your friend wasn’t interested in trying again. We love Catherine Tate, over here.

      • It is definitely important to get the background if you’re going to watch the whole series. I just find it gets in the way of someone who just wants to see what the show is like. That’s why I recommend “Blink” or “The Girl in the Fireplace” to those types of people, because they require no background.

        ❤ Donna. I can never say that enough. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s